Monday, October 11, 2010

The I in team*

(As a side note, this was written prior to the Vikings game tonight. Of which, the first half led me to ponder what it really means packing lots of talented people together - doesn't mean they can work as a group. Second half though, made this disclaimer partly unnecessary... until the death with 1.30 to go in the fourth quarter. [VERY BAD WORD!!] Just learn not to throw those interception with less than 2 mins to go... learn from mistakes in the past. LEARN!)

As a young member of various organisations and movements I came to the realization that maybe I wasn't really a team player. After another couple of years as an undergrad (remember all the "group work"?) I pinpointed my problem a bit more. It's not really that I don't like working in a team. Actually, I love working in a team since I know that 1+1+1 can make 5, it's that I have two main issues.

First, I dislike working in a team where the leader is not good. (I guess it would be more honest to say "worse than I would be as a leader and maybe that I consider myself a decent one due to experience and training".) Second, I dislike working in a team where people don't pull their weight. (Probably need to clarify since this comment has led to accusations about being an elitist in the past.) The key thing is in the effort, not necessarily the execution! (And this sort of loops back to the leader thing, that a good leader imho does not ask impossible things from their underlings. Tough things, sure. Impossible things that don't fit their character - not so much.)

This all seems fairly obvious (at least to me). When you are hired to do a job, you take pride in doing the job well. And as long as that happens, there is no problem. Team work for everyone!

Well, I guess it's obvious where this is going?!

What happens when you encounter the other types of people... like the ones who either have no interest in doing a good job (I guess they can always end up in the fired pool?); the ones who have made it a talent to walk the thin line of doing "exactly that little in order not to be able to be fired but also not doing much at all"; or the ones, as I have discovered more in more recent times, actively try to undermine the team effort (hopefully in order to make themselves look good - I can only hope this is the reason since otherwise it is just plain stupid)?

Needless to say, the last category really pisses me off. The other two categories aren't making me happy either - and I wonder if this is one of the main concerns I have had the last couple of years. Where you work more with people who "only sees the pay check in the end of the month and don't really care too much about the job"? This isn't something I think it more common outside of science per se. I know a lot of people not in science who still take pride in doing a great job, maybe because they see it as  a moral thing to do? However, I do think that if you don't work hard and try and do the best you can - you'd probably get tossed out of science (or other competitive environments) pretty fast?

And the team work with people who don't pull their weight usually leads me to enter the "I'll do it myself since then at least I know it'll get done". It's not really the best solution, since it means more work for me, less work for them, and in pay I guess they "win". But at least I can stick to my morals and thoughts about doing a good job. And the job gets done (the most important thing!). Best solution would be to try and improve their work ethics... anyone see the mountain moving? Didn't think so.

Well, I won't go into details in regards to recent times, but I have been going to the gym a lot lately**. Adrenaline and frustration are best worked out on a heavy bag or a treadmill... and hopefully the feeling of accepting "enough is enough" and "it's ok to give up sometimes and stop trying to change people but the only thing you can do is to change your situation"will decrease since I do worry about where that feeling will lead me to do every once in awhile.

In certain less dark moments I guess I could see this as yet another "learning experience". But dang I am getting very tired of all this "learning through being sucker punched just because I believe in people". I don't want to end up building (more) shields and refraining from trusting people (even less than I tend to do anyway).

I guess I just don't get people. Period.


*reference to Buffy season 4 episode... as well as the sport term "There is no I in team", meaning that the team is one unit - comprised of individuals but they are not counted as individuals... only a team!

**I've managed to gain (!) weight (not more than 1 pound or so). Although, when measuring waist lines etc I've lost centimeters so... building muscle might be nice but it's throwing me off my "loosing weight effort" and making me even more annoyed... maybe just date the treadmill more and the punching bag less in the week to come.

7 comments:

Alyssa said...

These are things I hate about working in a "team" as well. The unfortunate thing is there will always be people who take advantage of the work ethic of others - those who "coast" through life and do the bare minimum to keep their jobs.

I have a very hard time giving up tasks to people like this as well, because I know I can get it done correctly and on time.

It's definitely frustrating, and I don't really have any advice!

Nina said...

Same here, no advice really but I share the feelings.
My long term "solution" to the problem is to become eventually the president of the world (or rather, a lab) and everyone will do as I want and if not at leasst I have the power to punish/fire them. I guess that is not eve na real solution, just a way out for me ...
Good luck!

chall said...

Alyssa: yes, I guess that is the truth... there will always be those people... and the only thing I can do is to try and not care too much ?! ;)

Nina: I like the president of the world... although, my guess is, people will hate me/you ^^ but I guess there is something to be said about the punishment (I wonder why there always seem to have to be a stick rather than a carrot for certain people. I work well with carrots. Lots of carrots = happy chall :) )

The bean-mom said...

Ah, sorry to hear of your frustrations... no wonder you've seemed unhappy with your job. I used to think of myself as a solitary worker, and I still love the independence and freedom of steering your own boat, so to speak... but I also really appreciate teamwork IF everyone is pulling their own weight and communicating well and on the same page. Actually, if you can get all that happening, teamwork kinda rocks.

Cath@VWXYNot? said...

I've struggled with this issue too, as has my husband and assorted other friends across multiple industries. In undergrad they always assigned groups alphabetically by last name, and I always got stuck with a lazy, lazy student who didn't care and never did his share of the work, leaving the rest of us to take up the slack. (He failed in the end. Karma!) I wonder if that's why I still default so easily to "I'll just do it myself, that way I know it'll get done right and I'll have full control"?

btw the way your clothes fit is, IMHO, a better measure of overall health than your weight is!

chall said...

Bean-mom; partly because of the job, partly due to some other things. I totally agree with your last sentence... key work is IF

cath> well, I guess it is good to know I'm not alone in these thou8ghts. Although, it's sort of sad that so many feel annoyed about the "forced group work". I wonder if some of it would be better if one had to specifically state which parts everyoine did. ... but then, imho, some group work doesn't lead to division of clear cut parts but as a joint effort things get done.

as for the clothes/weight; "the don't". fit i mean. I don't have any more pants... they all fall off, and the shirts are sagging and not really fitting either ;)

As for the weight, ww wants the graph to point downwards so I'll see what happens this week when I have sped up the cardio and downed the weights...

FrauTech said...

I am certainly experiencing the undergrad teamwork thing right now. I guess I hate it because even though more people should make something take less time it never works out like that. Even when my teammates are motivated and hard working I still always feel like I have to work more than I should if the work was split up evenly. It's like having a team somehow increases the work. But at work it's totally different for me, I want complete ownership and hate sharing tasks. Then I am pleasantly surprised when working with someone else actually lightens my workload. But then I think if you are working with someone in a lab or at work the situation has selected for people who are more ambitious than those who just happen to be in your class, so that helps as well.